rokassan wrote:These last three films were horrid anyhow. The acting was bad and Darth Vaders fall was pathetic. He was a spoiled brat and self serving. I imagined his fall much more tragic...doing the wrong thing for the right reason or something to that effect.All he was trying to do is figure out how to ressurect his girlfriend IF she died. I dont think Disney could do worse, unless they did it on purpose.
You hit the nail on the head here. Not that the films were terrible, but "I imagined his fall much more tragic." Lucas has said over and over that nothing he could have produced or had produced by other teams would ever have lived up to his fan's expectations. Lucas didn't ruin Star Wars. We did. We expected the magic of the first films, which most of us first saw as children, to carry on into adulthood with new films.
In an interview in January, Lucas basically said he didn't see a reason to make any more movies because people would hate them and hate him no matter what came out of it. He never wanted to run a corporation and has always wanted to go back to making films just for fun rather than to fill the wanton needs of a fan base. He's tired of Star Wars, and he wants to be a fan rather than a creator which is something he's never been able to do with Star Wars (last time he handed full control over for a project, we got Life Day and Wookie adult movies... sure you want this again?). Either way, Lucas IS still going to be involved - no way Disney would shut him out of the process, even if it was just to throw a "I like that idea" around now and again.
If you step back and look at the prequel trilogy objectively, you can see they aren't terrible movies. They aren't the best ever, no, but their target audience loves them. Kids find the worlds, characters, aliens, technology, and other aspects of the film fascinating. I love each and every movie for its own merits, even though Hayden Christensen's acting has a lot to be desired in Episode II.
As for Anankin's fall to Vader, the films simply don't have enough time to cover the deep personal relationship Anakin develops with Palpatine between the second and third film. Anakin feared losing Padme as he had lost his mother, so Palpatine played off those fears and encouraged them while also making Anakin think the Jedi were attempting to take over the Republic. It wasn't JUST because he thought his
WIFE (not his girlfriend) was going to die. And all this information comes just from the films, not the extended universe.
Don't watch Star Wars like an adult. Watch it like a kid. The films were awe inspiring, and the world that spawned from the films is more than any of us could have ever hoped for through toys, video games, cartoon spin-offs (have you SEEN the Clone Wars?!?). Lucas created this, and we shouldn't crucify him for mistakes that were made. We could all play Monday quarterback and say how we would have done things differently in the films, but it won't change the films as they are, and it won't change Lucas's artistic decisions whether we agree with them or not.
Will Disney ruin Star Wars? Only if we let them. Star Wars is a space opera - its not supposed to attempt to solve social problems or make a statement against a political idea. Its about good monks with laser swords fighting bad monks with laser swords while space ships shoot at other space ships while a smuggler gets a girl (spoiler?), green guys surprise us with their abilities, planets are made entirely of ice, desert, lava, and forest, aliens of many species are all over all the time, the good guys are the underdogs and the bad guys are faceless, and its simply a bunch of fun thrown around the hero's quest.
Finally, if you don't like a movie, don't watch it. Enjoy the ones you do. Same reason I'll let my wife see the Matrix but not the sequels. I didn't like them, they aren't that great, so I won't watch them. However, someone somewhere likes them enough to purchase them on DVD/BluRay/Laserdisc.
Speaking of Laserdisc, if you want a copy of the original theatrical release trilogy, I have an extra set of LaserDiscs for the trilogy
