Page 1 of 1

jamescjohnstone/edmontonwarhammer/Extremoth

Posted: Tue Apr 12, 2011 3:55 am
by MagickalMemories
James C Johnstone AKA Chris Johnstone

jamescjohnstone@hotmail.com
edmontonwarhammer@gmail.com
20 Elbow Place
St Albert, AB
Canada
T8N 6X3
As jamescjohnstone, he has a -26 ref. Edmontonwarhammer was created to avoid the rating. As of today, he also has one unresolved BTR against him.

Eric

Re: jamescjohnstone/edmontonwarhammer/Extremoth

Posted: Tue Jun 07, 2011 3:35 am
by MagickalMemories
Thanks to the dilligence of some BTown members, information on this dishonorable trader has been retrieved.
Unsurprisingly, he's violated BTown's rules and started a new account:

Extremoth
memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=47525
extremoth@gmail.com

7804 92 ave
Edmonton Alberta
T6c1r5

Be warned. This guy is BAD NEWS.

Eric

Re: jamescjohnstone/edmontonwarhammer/Extremoth

Posted: Tue Jun 07, 2011 8:19 pm
by tedwin183
I actually just made a trade with this guy. He sent me Behemoth and the Winterguard Riflecorp from Khador. He shipped first and I have received the models. I'm shipping him the models he agreed to trade for now. He may have broken the rules, but he's not a thief or anything.

Re: jamescjohnstone/edmontonwarhammer/Extremoth

Posted: Tue Jun 07, 2011 9:00 pm
by Stanislav
Tedwin, that's great...but someone who has made 3 accounts...isn't just the possibility of going rogue, it's WHEN he does.

Blatant disregard of the rules does not inspire confidence. That he had a hiccup in trading calls for a negative reference. As a trader, you have to just take that as it happens. Making another account to avoid that...bad juju. His place here has been earned, and others should be warned.

Re: jamescjohnstone/edmontonwarhammer/Extremoth

Posted: Tue Jun 07, 2011 9:42 pm
by MagickalMemories
tedwin183 wrote:I actually just made a trade with this guy. He sent me Behemoth and the Winterguard Riflecorp from Khador. He shipped first and I have received the models. I'm shipping him the models he agreed to trade for now. He may have broken the rules, but he's not a thief or anything.
Have you done your research on him before posting this message?

I'm thinking not, or you'd see that he has an open BTR report on him. According to the BTR, the promised items have STILL not been recieved.
How does that NOT qualify him as being a thief?

Does it change your opinion to know that I've had an intermittent, ongoing email conversation with the man since his banning? He's claimed that he's owed items buy other traders and wanted access to his PM's so he could prove it. He knew he was banned permanently but that, to help him, I intended on letting him back in to his PM's *only*, once the above trade was received by the person to whom it was due.
Instead, he went behind our backs almost immediately and broke our rules by starting a new account.

That does not exactly scream "honorable individual" to me! Present facts point to "untrustworthy," and "thief" to me!

Eric

Re: jamescjohnstone/edmontonwarhammer/Extremoth

Posted: Thu Jun 09, 2011 5:54 pm
by squalie
I had a trade going with Edmonton Warhammer when he got banned and now, coincidentally, I have a trade going with "Extremoth" that I foind was null/void when I logged in today.

Do I post the pm history in here? I couldn't find examples of that searching this particular forum. We made an agreement and I won't know if he made good until a few more days at least. Since we hadn't got to the point where he gave me his return address, do I have to send my part if I get something in the mail?

Re: jamescjohnstone/edmontonwarhammer/Extremoth

Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 4:07 am
by MagickalMemories
squalie wrote:I had a trade going with Edmonton Warhammer when he got banned and now, coincidentally, I have a trade going with "Extremoth" that I foind was null/void when I logged in today.

Do I post the pm history in here? I couldn't find examples of that searching this particular forum. We made an agreement and I won't know if he made good until a few more days at least. Since we hadn't got to the point where he gave me his return address, do I have to send my part if I get something in the mail?
You do not need to post the PM history at all.
You made a trade agreement. At this point, I would suggest that (a) you use one of the email addresses above to contact him or (b) wait a reasonable time (a week is reasonable) to see if you receive something - presuming he was sending first.
If you get something in the mail and don't send your part or return his items, you are stealing and commiting mail fraud. If you send the items back but do not pay him for his shipping costs it would be rather dishonorable, since he DID send his portion.

Eric

Re: jamescjohnstone/edmontonwarhammer/Extremoth

Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 4:47 am
by XBoxDude79
Interesting issue here, I also had just completed trade negotiations with this gentleman for some WM items. I'll contact him via the e-mail address' given and see if he still plans on sending (or has sent all readY). I didn't see the BTR on him though, unfortunately. I'll post with updates as I get them.


XBD

Re: jamescjohnstone/edmontonwarhammer/Extremoth

Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 8:56 pm
by skull boy
I am still waiting on him to send out his end of our deal. Hopefully he will come through. He has been in contact with me via private email since his ban. I will keep you updated.

Re: jamescjohnstone/edmontonwarhammer/Extremoth

Posted: Mon Jun 13, 2011 3:48 am
by XBoxDude79
This guy backed out on our trade, anyone who is waiting on items from this guy, I hope you didn't send first/simultaneous.

Re: jamescjohnstone/edmontonwarhammer/Extremoth

Posted: Mon Jun 13, 2011 4:43 am
by porkuslime
So start a Back Out Report on him.. but adding to the Hall of Shame post is discouraged.

Re: jamescjohnstone/edmontonwarhammer/Extremoth

Posted: Mon Jun 13, 2011 11:57 pm
by tedwin183
No, I didn't look at the BTR. He offered me a trade, I told him he needed to ship first since he had a lower rating than me and he did. Granted, I got everything in a soft shipping bag, the models almost completely destroyed...but he sent them.

I just emailed him with his hotmail email to see if he responds. Hopefully he responds.

Thanks for all the posts here.

Re: jamescjohnstone/edmontonwarhammer/Extremoth

Posted: Tue Jun 14, 2011 4:01 am
by MagickalMemories
Please, folks.
No more anecdotes in this thread. If you need to report something, there are 2 forums for doing that.

Thank you.

Eric